|
ETHICAL DIMENSIONS OF MANAGEMENT Winter, 2008 |
|
Lawrence.Ulrich@notes.udayton.edu |
|
EXAM 1: 2 OF 4 ESSAYS TO BE SUBMITTED
THREADED DISCUSSION ATTACHED TO EXAM 1 BEGINS JANUARY 28 THREADED DISCUSSION ATTACHED TO EXAM 1 ENDS FEBRUARY 4
|
Directions:
You are to write two
(2) essays selected from the four (4) essays below.. The essays should
be about one to one and one-half (1-1&1/2) pages in length (about 300-500
words), typed double-spaced in MS Word. [SUBMISSION SHOULD BE
BY E-MAIL ATTACHMENT AND NOT BY INCORPORATING YOUR ANSWER
INTO AN E-MAIL MESSAGE: <Lawrence.Ulrich@notes.udayton.edu>]
You are to (1) recount what the authors you have read on the topic have
said, (2) try to relate ideas with each other, and (3) state your own reactions/reflections
about the issues under exploration. Please be clear about where your opinion
begins. You should not merely state an opinion but give carefully considered
reasons
for your opinions. Remember that this is a philosophy course and the reasons,
which you develop and organize to support your opinions, will be more important
than the opinions themselves. Ultimately you should demonstrate that you
(1) have read the text(s), (2) are familiar with the ideas, (3) have thought
about them carefully, and (4) have been able to formulate soundly based
opinions as a result of the reading you have done.
1. We talk a good deal about leadership in Business when we are exploring the Ethical issues in Business practices. How does the notion of the virtue life of managers fit into this discussion? What virtues do you think are particularly important for managers to practice in the exercise of their leadership. Why are the virtues you have selected essential for effective leadership?
2. Explain the fundamental tenets of Utilitarianism. Do you think this is a good Ethical System to use to assess business practices? Explain. Do you see any problems with applying it to business practices? Explain. It might be helpful to use a case to illustrate the points you are making.
3. Look at what the textbook author says about
the relativist perspective on pages 155 and 156. What does this perspective
mean? Do you think it is a good way to approach business practices? Explain. Do
the Ethical Systems that you studied in the first two weeks of the course
provide a reasonable alternative to the relativist perspective? Explain.
4. Explain the principle of justice and how it should be used in corporate
practices, particularly with regard to those practices, which provide goods and
services for consumers. It would be helpful to use a case to illustrate the
points you are making.
Directions and Specifications for the Threaded Discussion Attached to This Examination --- CLICK HERE.
THREADED DISCUSSION TOPIC:
Look at Case 5 in the textbook on page 343. Also, the reading about Martha Stewart and insider trading on Week 5 could be helpful. Discuss the case of Martha Stewart and the broader issue of insider trading from the deontological perspective. Is this perspective a good one to use for this situation? Or is another perspective better to give an ethical assessment of Ms. Stewart and insider trading? Obviously, since this is a philosophy course, you have to give reasons for positions that you take. I will be looking for assessments of the case but also your assessments of each other positions.
This TD1EX will run from January 28 to midnight of February 4. Groups will be assigned at the time of the posting.