KANT ON LYING
|
EXCHANGE OF SENTIMENTS=PRINCIPLE FACTOR IN SOCIAL INTERCOURSE. | |||||
|
WITHOUT TRUTH SOCIAL INTERCOURSE IS VALUELESS.
|
|
"PROCLIVITY TO RESERVE AND CONCEALMENT IS DUE TO THE WILL OF PROVIDENCE THAT THE DEFECTS OF WHICH WE ARE FULL SHOULD NOT BE TOO OBVIOUS." |
|
CONCEAL OUR FAULTS TO APPEAR OTHER [BETTER] THAT WE ARE. | |
|
ATTEMPTS TO APPEAR GOOD ULTIMATELY MAKE US REALLY GOOD. |
|
ABSOLUTE SILENCE [NO VALUE] VS. PRUDENT RESERVE [CAREFUL DELIBERATION. | |
|
SECRETS. |
|
ADD INTEREST TO CONVERSATIONS. | |
|
GIFT GIVEN. |
|
MUST EVERYTHING BE TOLD IF THE INTENTION IS TO SPEAK OUR MIND? |
|
FALSILOQUIUM - FALSE DECLARATION WHEN I INDICATE I INTEND TO SPEAK MY MIND. | |
|
FALSILOQUIUM - DECEPTION WITHOUT A STATEMENT --- OTHERS DRAW A CONCLUSION. | |
|
FALSILOQUIUM - HIDE FROM ANOTHER WHAT IS ON MY MIND; THE OTHER ASSUMES THIS IS HAPPENING; THE OTHER'S PURPOSE IS TO MAKE A WRONG USE OF THE TRUTH. |
|
FALSILOQUIUM BECOMES A MENDACIUM (LIE) WHEN IT VIOLATES THE RIGHT OF AN INDIVIDUAL. |
|
LYING IS AN INFRINGEMENT ON THE RIGHTS OF HUMANITY. | |
|
LYING VIOLATES HUMAN AS MORAL LEGISLATORS. |
|
"ALTHOUGH I DO A MAN NO INJUSTICE BY LYING TO HIM WHEN HE HAS LIED TO ME, YET I ACT AGAINST THE RIGHT OF MANKIND, SINCE I SET MYSELF IN OPPOSITION TO THE CONDITION AND MEANS THROUGH WHICH ANY HUMAN SOCIETY IS POSSIBLE." |
|
LYING DOES NOT ALLOW ME TO SATISFY MY CRAVING FOR KNOWLEDGE. |
|
NOT EVERY UNTRUTH IS A LIE --- ONLY WHEN WE EXPRESSLY GIVE ANOTHER TO UNDERSTAND WE ARE SPEAKING OUR THOUGHTS. |
|
BECAUSE HUMAN BEINGS ARE MALICIOUS, ALWAYS TELLING THE TRUTH IS OFTEN DANGEROUS [WHITE LIES ARE ENFORCED BY PRACTICAL NECESSITY]. |
|
WHAT COUNTS AS NECESSITY? |
|
"THE FORCING OF A STATEMENT FROM ME UNDER CONDITIONS, WHICH CONVINCE ME THAT IMPROPER USE WOULD BE MADE OF IT IS THE ONLY CASE IN WHICH I CAN BE JUSTIFIED IN TELLING A WHITE LIE." [EVEN SO, THE BRAVE AVOID THIS.] |
|
CHEAT = LYING PROMISE. |
|
AN INSULT TO THE PERSON TO WHOM IT IS MADE. |
|
USE OF EQUIVOCATION --- WHEN ONE IS TRYING TO EXTORT A TRUTH FROM US. | |
|
"A LIE IS A LIE, AND IS IN ITSELF INTRINSICALLY BASE WHETHER IT BE TOLD WITH GOOD OR BAD INTENT. FOR FORMALLY A LIE IS ALWAYS EVIL; THOUGH IF IT IS EVIL MATERIALLY AS WELL, IT IS A MUCH MEANER THING." |
|
A LIAR IS A COWARD WHO CANNOT ACHIEVE HIS ENDS BY OTHER MEANS. |
|
THERE IS DEFENSE AGAINST VIOLENCE; NO DEFENSE AGAINST A LIE. | |
|
JUDGE THE OUTER MANIFESTATIONS OF MORALITY --- WE CANNOT JUDGE THE INNER CORE. |