The word "case," common in everyday language, is a basic legal
term with at least three meanings: (1) the subject of a lawyer-client
relationship; (2) a trial, hearing, or other formal proceeding; and (3)
the written opinion of a court or another ajudicatory body.
The first use of the word "case" concerns the lawyer's role of
representation. "I took on three new cases today," says an attorney,
meaning that the attorney opened three new "files." These may be
three new clients, or perhaps two new clients and a new "matter" for an
existing client. The word "case" in this sense frequently means an
adversarial situation -- a dispute such as a divorce, a criminal prosecution,
a medical malpractice claim -- or a seemingly non-adversarial matter that
has the potential for becoming adversarial -- such as a will, an incorporation,
or a property settlement.
Legal disputes generally fall into two categories, criminal and
civil. In the former, a governmental body represents the interests
of the public at large against an individual accused of a crime.
In the latter, private or public parties oppose other private or public
parties in non-criminal legal matters. Approximately ninety percent
or more of all legal disputes are resolved outside the formal legal arena
of the courtroom, some before formal legal proceedings are filed in a court
or administrative agency and some after such proceedings are filed.
Such resolutions are usually referred to as settlements in civil cases.
In criminal cases, such resolutions usually result in charges being "dropped"
or a guilty plea being entered pursuant to a plea bargain.
Those legal disputes that do not "settle," or that settle only
after some activity in a formal legal arena, lead to the second use of
the word "case," meaning either a trial or hearing before an administrative
agency or a court, or an appeal to a higher court. "I've got three
cases next week," says an attorney, meaning that the attorney has three
trials or hearings set in various courts. Those adversarial legal
disputes that do not settle and are resolved in court lead to the third
use of the word "case," meaning a written judicial opinion issued by a
court. "The Supreme Court handed down the Jones case yesterday."
The published opinions of appellate courts account for most of the pages
in law school textbooks. "I briefed four cases for tomorrow's class."