Rel
375 - 08. Honors. Written Assignments.
At eight points in the course you will be
asked to hand in a one-page 1.5-spaced response to assignments listed
below. See the
course calendar for the due dates for each of these. Each is worth up to 10
points, except the critique of Hume and Geisler, worth 20. See below for instructions on this.
(You can use 10 point type --
preferably Ariel in that case for ease of reading -- to help get it all on one
page, or you can set the top and bottom margins to .8 each if you want more
room. But please make the side margins one full inch each [Word sometimes
uses 1.25 as the default for left and right margins]).
Depth of reflection and clarity about
specifics will count in your favor. The point of these assignments is to get
you thinking about relevant issues before you arrive at class, so that
discussions in class can be a little more thorough and complex than they
might otherwise be.
1. Introduction. Due Mon. Aug. 25.
On p. 4 read the four types of relations that may exist between religion and
science. Identify which of these seems closest to the actual situation today and
which furthest. Explain why you arrive at these conclusions, citing specifics
you have heard or read about. You need not be highly knowledgeable about
religion and science to answer this well. I simply want you to explore what sort
of presuppositions you might have going into this course.
2. Chapter One: Due Wed. Aug. 27.
a. Pp. 10-11 list eight different positions concerning
"faith." Select the one that appeals most to you personally as well as the one
which appeals to you the least, and explain why in each case as best you can.
Give your own best estimate of how many students at UD probably agree with you,
giving some reason why you arrive at this estimate (e.g., you have talked to
people about this in the residence halls).
b. Pp. 16-17 list 9 different methods for arriving at
or sustaining religious faith. Identify the one that is truest of you and the
one that is least true of you, explaining a bit in your own words. Which of
these nine do you think is most common among religious people in general?
3. Chapter Six. Due Wed. Sept. 17
Page 60 describes three different notions of God. Subsequent chapters will refer
to these frequently. Respond personally to each of the three, explaining which
of these you like, if any, and which have little or no appeal to you. Also
indicate which of the three forms of naturalism you agree or disagree with.
State whether your ideas about God are consistent with your position on the
various naturalisms? (If you are entirely consistent, you need only state this
bluntly, without further elaboration.)
4. Chapter Seven. Due Mon., Sept 22.
Pp 76-78 provide descriptions of the positions of both Richard Dawkins and
Alaister McGrath. Which of these two is more persuasive for you? Explain why. To
what extent do you agree with the first part of Karl Rahner’s approach, his
description (78-79) of human consciousness; has this been your own sense of what
we humans are like?
5. Chapter Eight. Due Mon., Sept. 29.
On pp. 81-82 you will find six definitions of the word "miracle." Figure out and
explain which of these is not compatible with cosmological naturalism. (Pp.
82-84 contain two lists of miracles in which people have believed at some time
or another. You can use these as tests of what you think about miracles.)
6. In relation to Chapter Ten. Due Mon., Oct. 6.
You will receive a handout of materials by David Hume and Norman Geisler. This
is more than usual to read, so this response paper is worth up to 20 points, and
can be longer than a page. Assignment: explain which of the two is more
persuasive to you and why. [FYI: I am using Hume because his ideas are by far
the most prominent reference point used by those discussing miracles. This is
famous stuff.] SEE BELOW FOR INSTRUCTIONS ON THIS ASSIGNMENT.**
7. Chapter Seventeen. Due Monday, Nov. 10.
This chapter initiates an exploration of human nature. On page 171 you will find
six notions of the inner self. Pick the one or two, modifying them as needed,
that come closest to your beliefs about the inner self. Then indicate why you
think that belief is correct. If it is based on your religious ideas, go back to
pp. 16-17 to identify which of the list of supports for faith there comes
closest to your own reasons.
8. Chapter Nineteen. Due Monday. Nov. 17. Two part assignment:
Pages 198-199 contain brief outlines of notions of "freedom." 1)
Give a detailed example -- real or fictional -- of a) an instance of the
exercise of external freedom and b) of an instance of the exercise of internal
freedom. 2) Many first year
students have told me they value spontaneity (external freedom by itself) much
more than the careful exercise of reflection and choice (internal freedom). Do
you agree? Why or why not?
**ASSIGNMENT ON HUME AND GEISLER
Two-page Critique
about the Hume & Geisler readings,
1. First identify the brief reason Hume gives why miracles are not easily
believable in any case. 2. Then summarize Hume's reasons why testimony to miracles -- i.e.,
reports about miracles made by others -- are probably not reliable. 3. Summarize Geisler's response to Hume
4. State which points by Hume and Geisler make sense to you and
why.
|