|
Physicians for Human Rights
Joint Intervention with Professor Vernellia Randall of
the University of Dayton School of Law and the Institute on Race,
Healthcare and the Law
Submitted to the World Conference Against Racism,
Regional Preparatory Meeting for the Americas, December 4-7, 2000
Theme 5: Strategies for achieving total and effective
equality, including international cooperation in the fight against
racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and other forms of intolerance
Thank you Mr. Chairman. Good Afternoon everyone, my name is
Lorraine Anderson and I represent Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) This
is a joint intervention between PHR and Professor Vernellia Randall of
the University of Dayton Law School in Ohio USA and the Institute on
Race, Healthcare and the Law.
Health is an essential precursor to the enjoyment of all other human
rights and should be available and accessible on an equal basis for all.
Members of racial and ethnic minorities in every society are equally
entitled to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health.
In the Americas, racial and ethnic minorities, especially Indigenous
peoples and Afro-descendents, have poorer health status than the
majority populations in their societies. This disparity is due to
barriers these groups face in accessing healthcare systems such as lack
of resources to pay for care that is not provided by the states, and the
absence of appropriate services in their communities. Those fortunate
enough to access health care are essentially relegated to inferior care
as a result of race bias in the diagnosis and treatment they receive.
Health status affects the range of decisions and possibilities open to
individuals. For indigenous peoples, Afro descendents and other racial
and ethnic minorities in the Americas, good health is crucial, as it is
at times the only fungible asset to which these disenfranchised groups
may lay claim.
Policies that have the purpose or effect of producing unequal access
to health care systems, or producing racial and ethnic biases in the
diagnosis and treatment of racial minorities, are policies of racial
discrimination. They are an affront to human dignity and a disavowal of
the principles, fundamental freedoms and human rights set out in the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international documents.
We therefore request that this conference acknowledge that racism is
a major health determinant for Indigenous peoples, people of African
decent and other racially marginalized groups which has an especially
profound effect on women in these groups. It is there for important for
the health status of these groups to be documented and understood so
that racial discrimination in health care can be eradicated. We request
that member states take effective action to remedy this health crisis
including:
- routinely and systematically collecting race and gender data on
health status and health care; such data should not be limited to
census and vital statistics but include data on access and quality (
particularly services delivery, diagnosis and treatment, facility
availability, provider availability and other related health
activities and services);
- ensure that health care providers are trained to provide
culturally appropriate care and that members of afro-descent
communities, indigenous communities and other racial groups are
adequately represented as health care providers and;
- provide effective mechanisms for the monitoring and elimination of
health care racism; such efforts should include effective
anti-racism laws which provide an adequate institutional framework
for redress.
- urge the member states of the Inter-American system to formulate,
approve and ratify additional protocols within the American
Convention on Human Rights (the San Jose Pact) that will incorporate
rights and protections for racially discriminated groups.
If discrimination in health care is left unchecked, racial and ethnic
minorities, especially Indigenous people and Afro descendents, will
never be able to fully enjoy the inalienable rights they share with all
other members of the human family. Unless concrete steps are immediately
taken to put an end to this health crisis, we are banishing yet another
generation of racial and ethnic minorities to a life in which they will
not be able to realize their full potential |