WASHINGTON — Growing up in the palest of Chicago suburbs, Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton had some of her earliest exposures to African-Americans through field trips. She sat in the back of her father’s Cadillac as he detoured through the inner city, cautioning her about the fate of people who, in his conservative Republican view, lacked the self-discipline to succeed.
She took a sociology course at Wellesley College that included a trip through Boston’s poor areas. On Tuesdays, she went to a housing project in Cambridge to mentor “underprivileged Negroes,” as she wrote to Don Jones, her minister back home, who had taken her to hear the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. speak in Chicago four years earlier.
In a presidential campaign in whic race has become a dominant
issue, Mrs. Clinton’s early brush with Dr. King has been a
recurring theme, invoked as a kind of “a-ha” episode to explain
her coming of age on race. Yet Mrs. Clinton’s passage from
sheltered Park Ridge, through the ferment of the civil rights
era, to competing for black votes across the South, has been
more gradual and introspective.
She spent 1964 volunteering for the Republican presidential
campaign of Barry Goldwater, a fervent opponent of the Civil
Rights Act. She awakened politically in the combustible 1960s,
but took a cooler approach to the civil rights movement. She
demonstrated for racial equality, but it was just one of the
items on her activism list (which included protesting the
Vietnam War, agitating to allow cars on campus and fighting for
the legal interests of children).
In promoting her civil rights record, Mrs. Clinton takes a
sweeping view, incorporating a great deal of her work for the
vulnerable and underserved — taking on juvenile-justice issues
for the Children’s Defense Fund, leading a commission on
education reform in Arkansas promoting the Family and Medical
Leave Act as first lady. (Her campaign’s two-page list of civil
rights accomplishments begins, at age 14, with the King field
trip.)
“I do have a broader definition,” Mrs. Clinton said in an
interview. “Civil rights are what each of us as human beings are
entitled to in relationship to our society. But it really is, at
core, about the respect and dignity of each human being.”
Frayed Good Will
Mrs. Clinton has seen her support among blacks as central to her
political identity. She has had many African-American friends
and advisers, racially diverse staffs and a Senate voting record
that has earned straight A’s from the
N.A.A.C.P. Even her
rival, Senator
Barack Obama , said in a
debate that he is “absolutely convinced” of Mrs. Clinton’s
commitment to racial equality.
But that career’s worth of good will became somewhat frayed
after supporters of Mrs. Clinton’s campaign — and chiefly, her
husband — were accused of racially tinged attacks and innuendo
against Mr. Obama before the South Carolina primary. Mr. Obama
went on to rout Mrs. Clinton on the strength of strong support
from blacks, a constituency Mrs. Clinton had courted hard.
The tone of the Clinton campaign deeply dismayed some
African-Americans who had been close to the Clintons, including
Eric Holder, a former top Justice Department official and Obama
supporter. “It places their legacy at risk,” Mr. Holder said.
Even as the charged rhetoric of South Carolina subsides, race
will no doubt persist as a theme for as long as Mr. Obama is
running, the contest is close and emotions run raw. “I think
everyone is trying to find their way, here,” Mrs. Clinton said.
Just as Mrs. Clinton has enjoyed the residual benefits of her
husband’s popularity with blacks, she has also been tarred with
the perceived failures of his administration. Any number of
African-Americans, despite their support for
Bill Clinton in the
1990s, still bristle over some episodes — from his criticism of
the rapper Sister Souljah during the 1992 campaign to his
welfare reform bill in 1996 to the number of black prisoners
incarcerated during his administration.
“The policy record of the Clinton administration on civil rights
is more mixed than people generally acknowledge,” said
Christopher Edley Jr., the law school dean at the University of
California, Berkeley, who served in the Clinton administration.
He cited Mr. Clinton’s unwillingness to intervene in Rwanda,
where hundreds of thousands died in tribal war, and his signing
of what Mr. Edley called “a horribly punitive crime bill.” Mr.
Edley said he remains fond of both Clintons but is supporting
Mr. Obama.
Circumstances have put Mrs. Clinton in a delicate position: as
the main obstacle to the first African-American with a serious
shot of becoming president. “Hillary’s in a tough spot. We’re
all in a tough spot,” said Representative James E. Clyburn, the
Democratic House whip, and influential black leader from South
Carolina. “You have two big dreams converging at the same time.”
While she has built her presidential campaign on “35 years of
experience making change,” her first 25 years were arguably more
central to shaping her views.
The city of Park Ridge, 15 miles northwest of Chicago, was
mostly devoid of blacks, Hispanics and liberals — which was fine
with Hugh Rodham, who was not shy about flinging prejudices
across the dinner table. “He had the views that people of that
age and time did,” Mrs. Clinton said.
She recalled her father’s driving her through rough parts of
Chicago. “We’d go by skid row, which is what it was called in
those days,” Mrs. Clinton said, “and we’d see some fellow
leaning against a lamp post, and my father would start in on one
of his usual lectures.”
Over time, she said, he mellowed. “His experience really
undermined and contradicted” his earlier views on race, she
said.
First Awareness
Mrs. Clinton recalled first being aware of racism a half-century
ago, at age 10, when she saw the televised images of black
students in Little Rock, Ark., being blocked from attending
school by order of Gov. Orval E. Faubus.
"There were these pictures of these mobs, and these children
trying to go to school, and it seemed so wrong,” she said in the
interview, conducted by phone. “I used to go to Sunday school
and sing ‘Jesus Loves the Children of the World,’ and I just
couldn’t believe it.”
Her biggest early influence on race was Mr. Jones, who led the
youth group at Park Ridge’s First United Methodist Church. He
took the teens to meet with poor black children at a community
center and chaperoned the expedition to see Dr. King, whose
speech that Sunday night bemoaned the indifference of the
privileged to the plight of the poor. The young Hillary Rodham
was inspired to volunteer to baby-sit for the children of
migrant farmers.
Still, she adopted her father’s staunch Republicanism, even
working for Mr. Goldwater’s campaign. Today, she laughs off her
“Goldwater Girl” period as a youthful indiscretion — and indeed,
she was 16 at the time.
“One of the first things I knew about Hillary was that she was
Republican and had been a Goldwater Girl,” said Janet McDonald
Hill, a black Wellesley classmate. That biographical nugget
comes up surprisingly frequently among Obama backers.
“Being a supporter of Barry Goldwater during the civil rights
revolution is about as close to original sin as I can imagine,”
said Mr. Edley, the Berkeley law school dean, who is
African-American.
Mrs. Clinton made her first black friend in college: Karen
Williamson, one of six African-Americans in her freshman class
at Wellesley. They went to church together one Sunday, which
upset Mrs. Clinton’s parents and led her to question her
motives. “Look how liberal that girl is trying to be, going to
church with a Negro,” Mrs. Clinton wrote to Mr. Jones, imagining
her reaction if she had seen another white girl doing the same
thing.
As a sophomore, Mrs. Clinton volunteered as a “Big Sister” to a
7-year-old black girl whose mother, a single housekeeper, needed
child care. Mrs. Clinton helped the girl with homework, took her
to movies, took her to dinner at
Harvard .
Mrs. Clinton brooded over the nature of privilege, suffering and
race. In a letter to a high-school friend, John Peavoy, she
spoke of “the depression that descends on a person, especially
one who has led a ‘sheltered suburban life,’ when he is
confronted with the realities of city life.”
In the fall of 1966, she attended a “black power” meeting hosted
by the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee but disapproved
of the group’s extreme “attitude toward civil disobedience,” as
she wrote to Mr. Jones.
After Dr. King’s assassination in 1968, she attended a rally in
Boston’s Post Office Square. Then the college government
president, Mrs. Clinton discouraged a campus organization of
black women from initiating a hunger strike to protest
Wellesley’s sparse African-American enrollment and
(non-existent) black faculty. She pushed instead for a two-day
student strike.
Mrs. Clinton said she came to believe that “taking to the
streets” and “giving speeches” was not enough to stir real
change — a claim that would foreshadow much of her advocacy
work, as well as one of her recurring critiques of Mr. Obama.
After Wellesley, she went to
Yale Law School. Though
it teemed with radical activism in the early 1970s — and New
Haven was aflame over a Black Panthers murder trial — Mrs.
Clinton immersed herself in the less inflammatory field of child
advocacy. She provided legal help for victims of child abuse and
volunteered at New Haven Legal Services, spending months on a
case involving a foster mother at risk of losing custody of a
2-year-old girl.
A Move to the South
By the time Mrs. Clinton moved to Arkansas in 1974, she had
acquired a number of African-American friends and colleagues.
She also had difficulty accepting what she saw as remnants of
the “Old South.” She was appalled that Mr. Faubus, the
segregationist governor, still had a following and opposed Bill
Clinton in the Democratic primary for governor in 1986. Mr.
Faubus lost with 33 per cent of the vote. (“You could put a
chicken on the ballot,” she says now, “and he’d get 30
percent.”)
In the interview, Mrs. Clinton recalled meeting Mr. Faubus in
the mid-1970s. She described him as talented, beginning his
gubernatorial career as a progressive who improved roads,
schools and mental hospitals. “And
then he made a Faustian bargain in 1957 because he threw his lot
in with the forces of darkness,” she said.
In Washington, as in Arkansas, Mrs.
Clinton viewed civil rights within her broader portfolio of
causes. Maggie Williams, her former chief of staff as first lady
and a current campaign adviser, said that those interests were
inevitably fused. “Low wages, poor health care and lack of
educational opportunities disproportionately impact people of
color in this country,” Ms. Williams said.
Professor
Lani Guinier of Harvard
Law School, who is supporting Mr. Obama, said the key
distinction between Mr. Obama and Mrs. Clinton lies in how they
view their relationship to power. In doing so, Ms. Guinier,
whose nomination as assistant attorney general for civil rights
in 1993 was pummeled by conservative groups and aborted by the
White House, referred to their respective biographies.
Mrs. Clinton “is the talented lawyer serving her clients,” Ms.
Guinier said. Mr. Obama is the organizer, she said, “who sees
the source of his power as the ability to inspire people to
mobilize.”
Referring to the possibility of the nation’s election of a
historic first, a black or a woman, Mrs. Clinton said last week,
“In a way, it’s a good problem to have. But it is a problem
