Document No. I-03-13
PROPOSAL TO THE ACADEMIC SENATE
TITLE: Graduate
Program in Intellectual Property and Technology Law in Cooperation with
SUBMITTED BY: Academic Policies Committee
DATE:
ACTION: Legislative
Reference:
Overview
The
University of Dayton School of Law (UDSL) proposes to offer two new graduate
degree programs:
1. A
“Master of Laws in Intellectual Property and Technology Law,” an LL.M. degree,
for students who already possess a first degree in law from a
2. A
“Masters in the Study of Law (Intellectual Property and Technology Law),” a
M.S.L. degree, for students who possess a baccalaureate degree in an area other
than law from a U.S. college or university or from a foreign university
authorized to confer such a degree by the government of the country in which it
is located.
The
programs will require students who possess a first degree in law from a U.S.
law school to complete a minimum of 24 course credits over two consecutive
full-time semesters of study at UDSL (August through May). Students who do not possess a first degree in
law from a
Requirements
1. For
LL.M. Candidates with a
A. Completion
of a minimum of 24 course credits.
B. Students
must complete a minimum of 6 course credits from the “Core” Intellectual
Property and Technology courses listed below.
While students may fulfill this requirement by demonstrating that they
have satisfactorily completed substantially equivalent courses at another law
school, credit for such equivalent courses will not be counted toward the 24
credit requirements for the LL.M. degree.
1) Intellectual
Property Law -- Law 790: 3 credits
2) Patent
Law -- Law 792: 2 Credits
3) Cyberspace
Law -- Law 774: 2 Credits
4) Electronic
Commerce -- Law 770: 2 Credits
5) Copyright
Law -- Law 811: 2 Credits
C. Students
may fulfill the remainder of their 24 course credit requirements from the
elective courses listed below as part of the Intellectual Property and
Technology Curriculum:
1) Licensing
Intellectual Property -- Law 798: 2 credits
2) Patent
Practice and Procedure -- Law 793: 3 credits
3) Protection
of Computers and Software -- Law 797: 2 credits
4) International
Intellectual Property -- Law 772: 2 credits
5) Intellectual
Property Law in the Digital Economy -- Law 773: 2 credits
6) Civil
Trial Practice - Law and Technology -- Law 825: 3 credits
7) Criminal
Law Seminar (Cybercrimes On-Line) -- Law 806: 3 Credits
8) Law,
Technology & the Workplace -- Law 844:
2 credits
9) Seminar
in Intellectual Property -- Law 777: (2 credits)
10) Seminar
in Cyberspace Law -- Law 776: (2 credits)
11) Externship
in Law and Technology -- Law 799: (2 credits)
12) Directed
13) Independent
Study for Graduate Students -- Law 607: 1-2 Credits
14 Administrative
Law -- Law 700: 3 credits
15) Federal
Taxation of Business Entities & Owners -- Law 814: 4 credits
16) Business
Planning -- Law 805: 3 credits
17) Commercial
& Business Drafting -- Law 881: 2 credits
18) Antitrust
Law -- Law 685: 3 credits
19) International
Law -- Law 795 : 3 Credits
20) International
Business Transactions -- Law 845: 3 credits
21) International
Tax Problems -- Law 860: 3 credits
22) Comparative
Law B Law 771: 3 credits
D. Students
may allocate a maximum of 6 credit hours of course work from non-Intellectual
Property elective courses from UDSL, approved courses in related fields from
other departments of the University of Dayton or approved courses in related
fields from another educational institution with the approval of the Associate
Dean and the Director of Graduate Programs at UDSL.
2. For
LL.M. Candidates with a Foreign Law Degree:
A. Completion
of a minimum of 30 course credits.
B. Completion
of the following two required courses:
1) Introduction
to the
This
course will introduce graduate students without a degree in law from a
2) Intellectual
Property Law for Graduate Students -- Law 790: 3 credits (Required Course)
(special section of existing course for graduate students without a law degree
from a
An
introduction to copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets, and related subjects for
graduate students. Examines the legal
protection for the creative work of authors and artists and the proprietary
information of businesses, the acquisition and duration of protection, and the
rights granted and remedies available for infringement.
C. Students
must complete a minimum of 6 course credits from the “Core” Intellectual
Property and Technology courses listed below.
While students may fulfill this requirement by demonstrating that they
have satisfactorily completed substantially equivalent courses at another law
school, credit for such equivalent courses will not be counted toward the 30
credit requirements for the LL.M. degree.
1) Patent
Law -- Law 792: 2 Credits
2) Cyberspace
Law -- Law 774: 2 Credits
3) Electronic
Commerce -- Law 770: 2 Credits
4) Copyright
Law -- Law 811: 2 Credits
D. Students
must fulfill the remainder of their 30 course credit requirements from the
elective courses listed above as part of the Intellectual Property and Technology
Curriculum.
E. Students
may allocate a maximum of 6 credit hours of course work from non-Intellectual
Property elective courses from UDSL, approved courses in related fields from
other departments of the University of Dayton or approved courses in related
fields from another educational institution with the approval of the Associate
Dean and the Director of Graduate Programs at UDSL.
F. Students
admitted to the UDSL Graduate LL.M. program pursuant to an International
Academic Cooperation Agreement between UDSL and an educational institution in a
foreign country may be subject to different degree requirements in accordance
with that Agreement. While such
Agreements may not alter the 30 credit hour minimum degree requirement or the
need to take the two required courses for students without a U.S. law degree
listed above in 2B, such Agreements may, for example, require that certain
additional courses be taken by the students or permit study in absentia
at the foreign educational institution which is party to the Agreement.
3. For
M.S.L. Candidates with a
A. Completion
of a minimum of 30 course credits.
B. Completion
of the following two required courses:
1) Introduction
to the
2) Intellectual
Property Law for Graduate Students -- Law 790: 3 credits (Required Course)
(special section of existing course for graduate students without a law degree
from a
C. Students
must complete a minimum of 6 course credits from the “Core” Intellectual
Property and Technology courses listed below.
1) Patent
Law -- Law 792: 2 Credits
2) Cyberspace
Law -- Law 774: 2 Credits
3) Electronic
Commerce -- Law 770: 2 Credits
4) Copyright
Law -- Law 811: 2 Credits
D. Students
may fulfill the remainder of their 30 course credit requirements from the
elective courses listed above as part of the Intellectual Property and
Technology Curriculum.
E. Students
may allocate a maximum of 6 credit hours of course work from non-IP elective
courses from UDSL, approved courses in related fields from other departments of
the University of Dayton or approved courses in related fields from another
educational institution with the approval of the Associate Dean and the
Director of Graduate Programs at UDSL.
4. For M.S.L. Candidates with a Foreign
Baccalaureate Degree:
A. Students
must fulfill the same requirements as students with a
B. Students
admitted to the UDSL Graduate M.S. L. program pursuant to an International
Academic Cooperation Agreement between UDSL and an educational institution in a
foreign country may be subject to different degree requirements in accordance
with that Agreement. While such
Agreements may not alter the 30 credit hour minimum degree requirement or the
need to take the two required courses for students without a U.S. law degree
listed above in 3B, such Agreements may, for example, require that certain
additional required courses be taken by the students or permit limited study in
absentia at the foreign educational institution which is party to the
Agreement.
Admissions
1. Admission
Requirements for the LL.M. Program
A. All
candidates for LL.M. program are required to have a first degree in law from a
B. All
candidates for the LL.M. program must be fluent in the English language. For foreign students whose native language is
not English, this requirement may be met:
1) By
having completed their basic legal studies in an English speaking country in a
university where instruction was in English.
2) By
taking the Test of English as a Foreign Language (TOEFL) test administered by
the Educational Testing Service and attaining a score of at least 600
(paper-based) or 250 (computer-based).
Scores from TOEFL tests more than two years prior to application to the
program will not be accepted.
C. All
candidates will evaluated for admission on academic and personal criteria
including law school transcripts, other academic records, employment experience
and other personal accomplishments.
Recommendations from past instructors, employers and others with
personal knowledge of the candidate’s past academic or personal accomplishments
will be considered.
D. Students
admitted to the UDSL Graduate LL.M. program pursuant to an International
Academic Cooperation Agreement between UDSL and an educational institution in a
foreign country may be subject to different admission requirements in
accordance with that Agreement. While
such Agreements may not alter the basic requirements of a first degree in law
or the required fluency in English, such Agreements may, for example, require a
minimum GPA for admission or the successful completion of a foreign graduate
school entrance examination or may permit a candidate to satisfy the English
fluency requirement with a lower TOEFL score together with supplemental
instruction in English as a foreign language at the University of Dayton.
2. Admission
Requirements for the M.S. L. Program
A. All
candidates for M.S. L. program are required to have a baccalaureate degree from
a
B. All
candidates for the M.S. L. program must be fluent in the English language. For foreign students whose native language is
not English, this requirement may be met:
1) By
having completed their basic baccalaureate studies in an English speaking
country in a university where instruction was in English.
2) By
taking the Test of English as a Foreign Language (TOEFL) test administered by
the Educational Testing Service and attaining a score of at least 600
(paper-based) or 250 (computer-based).
Scores from TOEFL tests more than two years prior to application to the
program will not be accepted.
C. All candidates
for the M.S.L. program must submit test results from one of the following
tests: the Law School Admission Test (LSAT), the Graduate Record Examination
(GRE), the Graduate Management Admissions Test (GMAT), the Medical College
Admission Test (MCAT) or other similar test.
Tests for admission to graduate programs administered by foreign
countries or institutions may, in the discretion of the Associate Dean and the
Director of Graduate Programs at UDSL, be considered in lieu of the above
listed tests. Applicants need not have
taken the LSAT for admission to the program.
The Associate Dean, the Director of Graduate Studies and the PL&T
Graduate Studies Committee at UDSL will consult with the appropriate offices at
the
D. All
candidates will evaluated for admission on academic and personal criteria
including university or college transcripts, other academic records, employment
experience and other personal accomplishments.
Recommendations from past instructors, employers and others with
personal knowledge of the candidate’s past academic or personal accomplishments
will be considered.
E. Students
admitted to the UDSL Graduate M.S.L. program pursuant to an International
Academic Cooperation Agreement between UDSL and an educational institution in a
foreign country may be subject to different admission requirements in
accordance with that Agreement. While
such Agreements may not alter the basic requirements of a baccalaureate degree
or the required fluency in English, such Agreements may, for example, require a
minimum GPA for admission or the successful completion of a foreign graduate
school entrance examination or may permit a candidate to satisfy the English
fluency requirement with a lower TOEFL score together with supplemental
instruction in English as a foreign language at the University of Dayton.
3. During
the first year of its operation the graduate program in law is expected to
enroll no more than 10 students. At its
maturity, graduate enrollment is not expected to exceed 30 students given the
need to avoid any adverse impact upon UDSL’s regular J.D. program.
Miscellaneous Provisions
1. Part-Time
Program: With the permission of the
Associate Dean and the Director of Graduate Programs of the
2. Faculty
All courses in the graduate program taught at UDSL
will be taught by full-time or adjunct faculty at UDSL. As a result, 3-4 full-time faculty members
who are identified with the field of intellectual property and technology law
will be instructors in the program.
Given the fact that the graduate program envisions the integration of a
small number of graduate students into the regularly scheduled intellectual
property/technology law courses currently offered to J.D. students,
establishment of the program should not necessitate the hiring of new faculty
or cause any appreciable adverse impact upon the faculty serving UDSL generally
or the PL&T program specifically.
The addition of two new courses reserved specifically
for graduate students will, of course, require finding a qualified faculty
member to teach those courses. However,
a number of current full-time and adjunct faculty have considerable experience
teaching similar courses and some have already indicated a desire to teach
those courses. The use of these faculty for these two courses should not have
an adverse impact upon the availability of courses for J.D. students.
3. Classroom Integration of Graduate and
J.D. Students
UDSL’s enrolled classes have routinely reflected an
array of students with widely diverse backgrounds and characteristics. The profile of the 2002 entering class shows
a range in ages from 20-48, a minority enrollment of 14.2%, and students from
over 100 colleges and universities representing 68 different majors. Among the entering class were students whose
baccalaureate degrees were from three foreign universities. In addition, UDSL has in the past permitted
non-J.D. post-baccalaureate students from the
Of course, some graduate students will not have had
the benefit of attending the first year of a
While there will be obvious language differences
between some of our foreign graduate students and J.D. students, admission into
the graduate program is only permitted to foreign students with a TOEFL score
of at least 600 (paper-based) or 250 (computer-based) and whose admissions
writing sample indicates a sufficient proficiency in English to benefit from
the program. In addition, the
Finally, the different legal, social, and cultural perspectives
that graduate candidates will bring to the classroom has the potential to
enrich class discussion and enhance the intellectual atmosphere of the classes,
providing international and interdisciplinary perspectives that will benefit
both the graduate and the J.D. programs.
4. Grading Standards
In order to insure that a lack of prior comparable
legal education experience does not have an adverse academic impact upon
students in the graduate program (or such an impact upon J.D. students in a
course with graduate students), graduate students in a class will be graded
upon a different standard than the J.D. students in the class. After the initial raw score grading of each
student in the class, faculty members will be asked to assign grades to graduate
students on the “graduate school standard” employed at the
5. Class Enrollment Priorities
Should competition for enrollment in classes arise,
students in the J.D. program will be given priority in enrollment over graduate
students for all courses offered in any semester at UDSL. However, graduate students admitted to the
program pursuant to an International Academic Cooperation Agreement between
UDSL and a foreign educational institution may be given priority over other
non-J.D. students seeking to enroll in any course offered at UDSL. While these enrollment priorities seem a
prudent way to avoid an adverse impact upon UDSL’s J.D. program, it is not
anticipated that such enrollment prioritization will be needed in most
instances. J.D. students will not be
permitted to enroll in the special courses offered only to graduate students
and enrollment in the intellectual property and technology courses in the Fall
and Spring semesters is seldom large enough to require enrollment restrictions
at the present time. Should graduate
students seek to enroll in courses outside the area of intellectual property
and technology law, the enrollment priorities noted above would be
applicable. As such, competition for
enrollment in upper-level courses between graduate and J.D. students is
unlikely and will be avoided should it ever occur.
6. Impact of the Graduate Program upon
UDSL Resources
It is not anticipated that the operation of the
graduate program will have an adverse impact upon the resources or facilities
available to the J.D. program.
The enrollment of graduate students at UDSL should
have little, if any, impact upon the facilities available to the current J.D.
program. During the regular academic
year, when graduate students will be integrated into the J.D. student
population, the addition of graduate students into the upper level classes
dealing with intellectual property or technology law will not tax the classroom
resources available at UDSL. UDSL has 4
large classroom seating 50-100 students, 5 professional skills rooms seating 25-30
students, three seminar rooms of various sizes, group study rooms (5-20
students), a Computer Training Center (30 students), and 1,400 data and power
outlets for students. These
capabilities, together with the relatively smaller enrollments in the classes
in which the majority of graduate students are expected to enroll, should prove
more than ample.
Interpretation 308-1 to ABA Approval Standard 308,
which governs the
One full-time faculty member will serve as the
administrator for the graduate program.
While these administrative responsibilities will, of necessity, have an
impact on the ability of that faculty member to engage in other service tasks
at UDSL, especially in the first few years of the program, it is anticipated
that, as the program matures, the burden associated with those administrative
responsibilities will diminish. This
seems likely given the fact that the Dean of UDSL has established a faculty
“PL&T Graduate Studies Committee” which will assist the director in making
the small number of admissions decisions that the program will entail and in
general oversight of the program. In
addition, as will be discussed in more detail below, the International Services
Office (ISO) of the University’s Center for International Programs will be
providing invaluable assistance to the graduate program and its students in the
form of orientation, insurance and immigration assistance and special services
for international students. Finally, the
addition of graduate students to the current student body will not place any
untoward burden on the highly efficient computer-based systems currently in
place for registration of students and the processing of student transcripts
nor require the addition of any new secretarial assistance.
7. Integration
of Foreign Graduate Students into
For international students, extended stays in a
foreign country, while exciting and fascinating, can often lead to a culture
shock that can be quite wearisome and frustrating before a full adjustment to
the new environment is made. The foreign
graduate students can be expected to experience the same cycle of fascination/culture
shock/adjustment during their stay in
Fortunately, the International Services Office (ISO)
of the University’s Center for International Programs has offered to assist the
Before students begin to seek admission to the
graduate program, UDSL will work closely with the ISO to design and implement
an orientation and student services program tailored to the needs of the
incoming international students.
Benefits of a Graduate
Program in Intellectual Property and Technology Law
1. To The
A. The
proposed Graduate Program will reflect the unique nature of UDSL’s Program in
Law & Technology and enhance its growing reputation.
The Program in Law & Technology (PL&T) at the
The scope and focus of the proposed graduate program
represents a logical continuation and enhancement of PL&T’s innovative
approach to the study and development of intellectual property and technology
law. According to the American Bar
Association, of the 188 accredited law schools in the
And unlike other graduate law programs that focus
merely upon intellectual property or computer law, UDSL’s program has a broader
focus that more accurately and realistically reflects the multifaceted
challenges that face entrepreneurs and their attorneys as the technological
revolution spreads across the globe.
UDSL’s proposed graduate program, like its PL&T Program, focuses on the application of law and public
policy not only to foster creativity, invention and innovation but also to
facilitate the transformation of those creative efforts into economic
development and competitive business advantage.
To those ends, the graduate program offers instruction not only in
intellectual property law and computer-related and cyberspace law, but also in
the business dimensions of intellectual property and the intricacies of
electronic commercial transactions.
As the goals, influence and expertise of UDSL’s
PL&T program expand and mature it seems logical that its pedagogical programs
expand as well. This innovative and
unique graduate program has the potential to greatly enhance the
B. The
proposed Graduate Program will attract a wide variety of new students to UDSL
by offering an educational “product” that, in some respects, is virtually
unavailable anywhere else in the
While 16
The
technological revolution and the globalization of the world’s economy have
greatly increased the influence and importance of
As a result, just as UDSL’s current PL&T program
draws students with a myriad of backgrounds to the study of Intellectual
Property and Technology Law, it can be expected that the proposed M.S.L.
program will have a similar broad appeal.
That attractiveness will be enhanced by the fact that the M.L.S. degree
is a one-year program which should appeal to students whose careers may benefit
from a background in intellectual property and technology law but who do not
wish to commit the necessary three years to obtain a J.D. degree. No other law school in the country offers
such an alternative to such students.
C. The
proposed Graduate Program will provide all students at UDSL with the important
benefits that can be derived from interdisciplinary and international
perspectives on the law.
The expected multi-disciplinary and international
appeal of and enrollment in the proposed graduate program promises to provide
all students at UDSL new and important perspectives during their study of law
at UDSL. As noted earlier, graduate
students will be integrated into the J.D. program at UDSL and that integration
will provide J.D. students with the varied perspectives on the study of law
that their international and non-lawyer graduate colleagues will provide during
classroom discussions and other less formal interaction.
2. To the
A. The
proposed Graduate Program is an integral part of UD’s “China Initiative.”
This graduate program in law is one of several
components of the University of Dayton’s China Initiative, a strategy designed
to “increase the internationalization and enhance the intellectual climate of
the University by pursuing opportunities in a country of substantial and
growing influence” in the world. That initiative has four primary goals:
1) the establishment of educational
partnerships with top Chinese universities,
2) the creation of programmatic affiliations
with rising new universities in
3) the provision of educational programs for
Chinese and
4) the establishment of UD as a leading
provider of educational services to the corporations doing business in the
Suzhou Industrial Park, a joint economic and technological project of the
Chinese and Singapore governments in which numerous high-profile U.S. and
foreign companies have made substantial financial investments.
While certainly relevant to all four of these goals,
the proposed graduate program in law is currently seen by UD’s administration
as a major component of the first and fourth goals. NJU is one of the PRC’s top five universities
and, in discussions with officials at NJU, great interest was expressed in the
establishment of a graduate degree in intellectual property and technology
law. In addition, NJU has received
permission from the PRC’s Ministry of Education to provide educational services
in the
B. The
proposed Graduate Program may serve as one component of UD’s response to Gov.
Robert Taft’s “Third Frontier Project.”
Gov. Taft’s proposed “Third Frontier Project” would
create partnerships between state and local governments,
The proposed graduate program, together with other
components of UDSL’s PL&T, could play an important role in UD’s response to
the “Third Frontier Project” by providing the needed research into the legal
aspects of protecting innovative products and manufacturing processes and by
providing both consultative and educational services for companies developing
these new products and processes. The
proposed graduate program promises to provide a opportunity for “Third
Frontier” researchers and company executives, as well as their lawyers, to
obtain the needed legal background to both protect and commercially develop
these innovative products and processes at a lower cost and in a shorter term
than the traditional 3-year J.D. degree program.
C. The
proposed Graduate Program may provide enhanced educational opportunities for
faculty and graduate students in the College and other Schools of the
University.
In the past, a UD faculty member or graduate student
outside of the law school whose area of expertise could be enhanced by a basic
understanding of the law governing that area had little opportunity to obtain
that legal background short of attending the 3-year J.D. program at the