2008 Presidential Election, Race and Racism
Professor Vernellia Randall
Speaking Truth to Power!

And Now Obama? Critical support


Send Letter to Secretary Hillary Clinton:
United States Must be fully Participate in United Nations Conference
 on Eliminating Racism (Durban Review).



Home March 13,2008 Hillary Clinton and Gearldine Ferraro     February 26, 2008 - Tim Russert;     February 21, 2008 - Bill O'Reilly;       February 20, 2008 - Bill O'Reilly;          January 30, 2008 - National Organization of Women - New York;          January 15, 2008  - MSBNC, Brian Williams and Tim Russert Discussion Forum
This site focuses on one issue: racial inequality. It does not endorse or oppose any party or any candidate.


Home                                                    x
Worst Person                               x
Institutional Racism                                    x
Inequalities & the Election                                  x
Race and Racism                              x
Racial Groups                                       x
World Perspective                               x
NAACP Questionnaire                            x
Primaries and Caucuses                             x
Site Map
This website is always under construction please email me  relevant links related to any of the candidates or to race and racism and the election.
African Americans                                         X
Asian Americans                                                   X
European Americans                         X
Latino(a) Americans                                          x
Native Americans                                 x
Pacific Islanders                                       x
Institutional Racism                                     x
01 Race and Racism                                     x
02 Citizenship Rights                                     x
03 Justice                                     x
04 Basic Needs                                     x
05 Intersectionality                                     x
06 Worldwide                                     x

Bill Fletcher, Jr
The Black Commentator

The withdrawal of the candidacy of former Senator John Edwards, coupled with the outcome of the Super Tuesday primaries, established that within the Democratic Party, there is a two person race for the nomination. The Super Tuesday results, more than anything, demonstrated that Senator Obama was clearly competitive with Senator Clinton. While Senator Clinton won the states she was expected to win, Senator Obama captured thirteen states, including locations where one would never have expected a victory, e.g., North Dakota.

So, let’s look at the scorecard and see where we are. No, not the delegate count, but the political scorecard. On the major issues, there is no significant difference between Obama and Clinton. Yes, there is some nuance, and, yes, Obama opposed the Iraq war. But as readers of my commentaries know, I have not discovered particularly fundamental differences.

Despite this, there is a clear Obama-mania underway and there are two aspects to this that we must address head-on. On the one hand, Obama is inspiring millions with the notion of “change.” Now, the “change” that is mentioned in speech after speech is very vague. When Obama speaks in concretes, e.g., attacking Al Qaeda bases in Pakistan unilaterally, there is nothing new and different about that approach. Yet what seems to be happening is that the disgust with the Bush years, combined with a reassessment of the Clinton years, is leading many people to look for something very different. This is in part generational, but actually much deeper than that. I emphasize this point because it is easy to write off the excitement as being naiveté. There is an unfocused desire to break with what the USA has been experiencing, both domestically and internationally, and it has come to be personified in Senator Obama, almost despite himself.

The other aspect, however, is more complicated and a bit unsettling. There has been a tendency, including among some progressives, to attempt to fashion Senator Obama as something other than what he is. Over the months, I have heard progressive commentators describe Senator Obama as if he were the second coming of the Rev. Jesse Jackson and his ’88 campaign. Surprisingly, Senator Obama is rarely challenged by credible progressives for the weakness of his platform and the lack of depth of his call for “change.” It’s as if we close our eyes, click our heels together, and repeat something to the effect of, the “change” will be progressive…the “change” will be progressive…

So, we are faced with this enigma. Some people, including some writers for The Black Commentator, are adamant that Senator Obama should not be supported and that he is a fraud. Others, including some writers for The Black Commentator, argue exactly the opposite. I am not going to argue the position of Solomon and suggest splitting the baby, but I will argue that critical support of the Obama campaign is an appropriate approach to take. Let me suggest why.

  • *First, and not in order of importance, the reality of the US electoral system and the state of progressive movements, is that we are a ways off from having a candidacy that is anti-racist, anti-sexist and anti-empire - at least a candidacy who can win. Unfortunately, we are in a period where we are compelled to address the lesser of two evils. In that sense, while I do believe that we could have had a winning candidate who was better on the issues than is Senator Obama, no such candidate prevailed in the primaries.
  • Second, there is little question but that Senator Obama has helped to ignite excitement and an electoral upsurge, though I would not describe it as a movement, at least not at the moment. This becomes a space in which progressive-minded people can and should be pushing the content of progressive change, rather than relying on mere rhetoric.
  • Third, the color line. While I adamantly object to those who yell - in support of Senator Obama - that “race does not matter,” the reality is that a successful Black nominee, not to mention an elected Black president of the United States, lays the foundation for a different discussion on matters including, but not limited to, race. This does not mean that a Black person automatically makes the environment more progressive (does anyone remember the name Clarence Thomas?) but it does mean that an individual who is liberal-to-progressive can open a door for discussion. We should not expect that he will walk through that door, but others of us may very well be able to.

My conclusion, and I offer this with great caution, is that critical support for Obama is the correct approach to take. Yet this really does mean critical support. It means, among other things, that Senator Obama needs to be challenged on his views regarding the Middle East; he must be pushed beyond his relatively pale position on Cuba to denounce the blockade; he must be pushed to advance a genuinely progressive view on the rebuilding of the Gulf Coast and the right of return for the Katrina evacuees; and he must be pushed to support single payer healthcare.

As I emphasized in an earlier commentary, it is up to the grassroots to keep the candidates honest. Silence, in the name of unity, is a recipe for betrayal. What we have to keep in mind is something very simple: the other side, i.e., the political Right, always keeps the pressure on. If we do not pressure, in fact, if we do not demand, the reality is that the Right will come out on top.

To do the right thing, we must assess and appreciate Senator Obama for who he is and what he is - politically - rather than engage in wishful thinking. To do anything else is to be disingenuous to our friends and our base. Senator Obama, if elected President, will be unlikely to reveal himself to have been a closeted progressive. Yet, with pressure from the base, he may be compelled to do some of what is needed, despite himself and despite pressures to the contrary.

Bill Fletcher, Jr. is Executive Editor of The Black Commentator. He is also a Senior Scholar with the Institute for Policy Studies and the immediate past president of TransAfrica Forum. Click here to contact Mr. Fletcher.



Discussion Forum


This Page Last Updated:
Thursday, July 03, 2008  

You are visitor number
Hit Counter  
Since February 9, 2008


Submit for Periodic Updates
Update List

DEMOCRATIC                   x
Obama                                                    x
REPUBLICAN                            x
McCain                                                    x
McKinney                                         x

This website is always under construction please email me  relevant links related to any of the candidates or to race and racism and the election.
Minnesota Public Radio                        x
WQAD  TV                             x
Australia - US Survey                                 X


Same level:
The Obama Bargain ] Barack Obama’s Speech on Race ] What Made Obama's Speech Great ] The Obama version of 'we shall overcome' ] Obama, Imperialism and the Paradox of Plenty amid Poverty ] Bringing race to the forefront ] If President, What Do White People Think Obama Will Do To Them? ] Obama's racing the wrong way ] Obama: The Attacks Have Only Just Begun ] Obama Race Speech Analysis by 14 Blackcommentator.com ] Can Obama avoid being the 'black candidate'? ] Defying Conventional Wisdom on Race and Politics ] Obama's rhetoric, American realities ] Barack Obama: Can he deliver? ] Obama Beer  (VIDEO) ] Obama: An Emotional Escape Hatch from the Bush Era ] [ And Now Obama? Critical support ] Obama's real fairy tale ] The Obama Effect: challenging the rules of race and politics ] Obama should be a colour-blind president ] Holding Barack Obama Accountable ] The Obama Messiah Watch ] Barack Obama's Messiah Complex ] Obama the Magic Negro! ] Gay Inclusion - Obama Playing Us Stupid ] Obama’s Identity Crisis ] Barack the Magic Negro ] Even to a conservative, there's hope for a President Obama ] O'Reilly: "I don't want to go on a lynching party * *  * unless * *  * ] Presidental Racism (VIDEO) ] Seismic Shift in Racial Politics ] Michelle Obama thesis was on racial divide ] Where is the Critical Thinking in this Campaign 2008? ] Race affects politics ] Obama’s White Male Voters ] Capitulation is the order of the day ] Obamarama: Is it a Movement? Or is it Marketing? ] Obama: "Wall Street's Presidential Brand" ] Obama Chastise Blacks to Allay Jewish Concerns ] Obama denounces pastor's comments ] Obama's Backpeddling is Just Starting ] Obama, Fractals and Momentum Politics ] Obama Played the Race Card ] Deeply troubled by Obama  racial politics ] The Political Wonder That Is Obama ] Barack: Back and Forth Voter ] What Obama Means By Unity ] Pundits blind to Obamas America ] Which bias runs deeper in the American psyche? ] Obama offers U.S. a chance to do its racial laundry ] Obama as "Honorary White Man" ] David Brooks on Republican Support of Obama ] West, Bennet, Ogletree on Obama (VIDEO) ] Seeking Unity, Obama Feels Pull of Racial Divide ] Do some people think Obama is an honorary white man? ] The dynamism and the danger of Obama ] Barack Obama and the Euphoria of Madness ] Jewish Leader  to Obama : ‘Confront Your Pastor’ ] Obama Photos Album ] Community Activist, Obama and the Few Bad Apples ] Analysis: Obama's Health Care Plan (VIDEO) ] Obama: Bamboozling America ] Obama a Contemporary Don Quixote? ] Obama, Fat Tuesday and the Big Hangover ] Obama vs. the Phobocracy. ] VIDEO - Obama Speech in Kenya ] Playing the Race Card ] Putting faith in Obama ] SubPrime Obama ] VIDEO - Yes We Can! ] What to Expect from an Obama White House ] Why Republicans Like Obama ] Fox Attacks Obama! ] Obama And The Bigots ] Let's face the music: there is an Obama in the GOP's future ] Obama's black support shows its limits ] Obama: Black president or “irrational exuberance”? ] IS endorsing Barack Obama the new cool? ] Tennesee GOP Backs off statement ]
Child Level:
Home ] Up ]
Parent Level:
January 2008 ] February 2008 ] August 2008 Updates ]
[Race and Racial Groups] [Citizenship Rights]  [Justice and Race] [Patterns of Basic Needs] [Intersectionality Issues] [Human Rights]

Always Under Construction!

Always Under Construction!

Copyright @ 2008
Vernellia Randall. All Rights Reserved

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, some material on this website is provided for comment, background information, research and/or educational purposes only, without permission from the copyright owner(s), under the "fair use" provisions of the federal copyright laws. These materials may not be distributed for other purposes without permission of the copyright owner(s).


Last Updated:
Tuesday, April 07, 2009  

You are visitor number
Hit Counter  
Since January 9, 2008