2008 Presidential Election, Race and Racism
Professor Vernellia Randall
Speaking Truth to Power!

Why Isn't Poverty an Issue?


Send Letter to Secretary Hillary Clinton:
United States Must be fully Participate in United Nations Conference
 on Eliminating Racism (Durban Review).



Home March 13,2008 Hillary Clinton and Gearldine Ferraro     February 26, 2008 - Tim Russert;     February 21, 2008 - Bill O'Reilly;       February 20, 2008 - Bill O'Reilly;          January 30, 2008 - National Organization of Women - New York;          January 15, 2008  - MSBNC, Brian Williams and Tim Russert Discussion Forum
This site focuses on one issue: racial inequality. It does not endorse or oppose any party or any candidate.


Home                                                    x
Worst Person                               x
Institutional Racism                                    x
Inequalities & the Election                                  x
Race and Racism                              x
Racial Groups                                       x
World Perspective                               x
NAACP Questionnaire                            x
Primaries and Caucuses                             x
Site Map
This website is always under construction please email me  relevant links related to any of the candidates or to race and racism and the election.
African Americans                                         X
Asian Americans                                                   X
European Americans                         X
Latino(a) Americans                                          x
Native Americans                                 x
Pacific Islanders                                       x
Institutional Racism                                     x
01 Race and Racism                                     x
02 Citizenship Rights                                     x
03 Justice                                     x
04 Basic Needs                                     x
05 Intersectionality                                     x
06 Worldwide                                     x

Caryl Rivers

Why did John Edwards' crusade against poverty find so little resonance in the media?

It seemed a perfect time for his message. In 2006, 36.5 million people were in poverty, and 35.5 million Americans lived in "food insecure" households, 22.8 million adults and 12.6 million children. On any given night in America, anywhere from 700,000 to 2 million people are homeless, according the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty.

Poverty in America is considerably higher today than it was in the 1970s and children are especially affected. The U.S. lags behind other developed countries in this area. While Denmark and Finland lead 26 participating OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) countries with child poverty rates below 3 percent, Mexico and the United States are at the other end of the spectrum, both with child poverty rates of more than 20 percent. (Maybe those folks who wade across the Rio Grande should just keep trekking North -- to Canada. )

Despite these facts, the press reaction to Edwards too often focused on what the Washington Post called the three H's -- Haircut, Hedge funds and House (his North Carolina estate.)

As Media Matters for America has reported, the media extensively scrutinized all of the above, "often baselessly suggesting that they conflict with his anti-poverty campaigning."

When Edwards announced a three-day, eight-state tour aimed at calling attention to poverty, the news media generally chuckled. The tour echoed Bobby Kennedy's poverty crusade in the 1960s, but the media seemed to regard Edwards' poverty tour as a gimmick. They also saw Edwards as just too pretty to be talking about poverty. Maybe he needed a face transplant from Johnny Cash to be taken seriously.

The news media has changed in many ways since Bobby Kennedy went on the road, and not for the better. Reporters used to be the people with their noses pressed to the window, looking in at the lives of the affluent. Today, they are often on the inside looking out. Big name journalists -- especially if they get on TV often -- command thousands of dollars in lecture fees. When I started out in journalism, reporters felt lucky if they could get three people to listen to them in a bar. They were more likely to follow the racing form than the stock market. Many of them actually lived in the down-at-the-heel neighborhoods that they covered.

Today, that's changed dramatically . A FAIR study found that in just over three years (9/11/03 - 10/30/06) the major TV networks, ABC, CBS and NBC, broadcast only 58 stories dealing with poverty in more than a passing mention.

It's a subject that has largely vanished from the media, deemed too depressing and unappealing to the affluent readers and viewers prized by advertisers. Where's the growth in journalism today? In infotainment and lifestyle journalism. If you're affluent and you want to know how to spend your money, just go to the nearest magazine rack or to your local newspaper. Coverage of food, fashion, furniture and high end housing eats up space. Late-breaking recipes trump stories about poverty.

Thomas Patterson, Bradlee Professor of Government and the Press at Harvard, found in a 2001 study that soft news has increased dramatically over the past two decades. News stories lacking public policy content jumped from less than 35% of all stories in 1980 to roughly 50% of stories appearing in 2001. Stories with a moderate to high level of sensationalism rose from about 25% of news stories in the early 1980s to a current tally of 40%. Stories that include a human interest element also figure heavily in contemporary reporting, accounting for less than 11% of news stories in the early 1980s, but more than 26% of reports by 2001.

It's no surprise that a "spiral of silence" has formed with regard to the coverage of poverty. Competitive pressures lead to fewer stories and the silence depends. Add to that the fact that few journalists today have personally experienced poverty, you find explanations for the often-mocking tone of the coverage of Edwards.

Even when John Edwards did well, he couldn't get a break. The Daily Kos notes that his coverage fell after he finished second in Iowa.

"There's no good reason for Edwards' coverage to fall the day AFTER the caucus. It should have gone UP not down; the news of Obama's victory had already been told, and Edwards' strong showing in Iowa should indicate a strong reservoir of support."

However, on the day of the caucus, Edwards received 41% of the mentions of either Edwards or Hillary; the day after the caucus, he received just 36%, despite narrowly edging Hillary out.

Given all the factors that influence the lack of coverage of poverty, this situation is going to worsen. The infrastructure of serious journalism is crumbling faster than our bridges and roads. So what to do?

One answer may be foundation funding, The Miami-based John S. and James L. Knight Foundation has launched a $25 million initiative to help newspapers cope with the new digital technology.

But as Dan Gillmor, director of the Center for Citizen Media Project (at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism) notes, "$25 million is a rounding error compared to what it will take nationwide (and, in fact, around the world) to come through this transition with a vibrant and diverse journalistic ecosystem..., foundations have the ability to support ideas that stem from motives other than big profits." One idea he suggests is that foundations pay the salary of an investigative journalist at a local newspaper.

They'd better hurry. Good journalism is collapsing just like that Minneapolis bridge, and that's sad news for the future of the republic.

Boston University Journalism professor Caryl Rivers is the author of "Selling Anxiety: How the News Media Scare Women


Discussion Forum

This Page Last Updated:
Thursday, July 03, 2008  

You are visitor number
Hit Counter  
Since February 9, 2008


Submit for Periodic Updates
Update List

DEMOCRATIC                   x
Obama                                                    x
REPUBLICAN                            x
McCain                                                    x
McKinney                                         x

This website is always under construction please email me  relevant links related to any of the candidates or to race and racism and the election.
Minnesota Public Radio                        x
WQAD  TV                             x
Australia - US Survey                                 X


Same level:
A Husband-Wife Debate: Obama v Hillary ] A New Type of African-American Politician ] A whiter shade of guilt ] Black and white world ] ColorBlind America - A Real Fairy Tale ] Obama VS. Clinton-Black Or White (VIDEO) ] The Irrelevance of Obama's Color ] The peril of pandering ] Racism and Sexism still count in elections ] Elements of ethnicity are now second to humanity ] The Ongoing Evolution Of Obama's "Post-Racial Politics" ] Race Card and Rep James Clyburn ] Understanding the Magic Negro ] Obama' Biggest Obstacle - Voter Suppression ] Some people are blacker than others. ] Chris Rock's 2008 Election Analysis (VIDEO) ] Democrat's Class War ] Democratic Family Splits ] Does Change of Face Mean Change of Pace? ] McCain, Obama or Clinton:  Bush Wins in 2008 ] The Daily Show – You’re Not Helping ] Dreams of 'a new Martin Luther King' ] I-Love-Obama-thus-racism-no-longer-exists phenomenon ] Jesse Jackson on the South Carolina Primary ] Lens of race persists ] Minimal Differences Between Clinton, Obama ] New York's Newest Citizens and the Election ] Plantation politics ] Polls show gender and race won't help or hurt candidates ] Psychological Gang Bang of Hillary ] Racial Diversity in Presidential Campaign Staff ] Racial Stereotyping & the Election ] Setting Up Easy Targets for Karl Rove ] Unfortunate Headline: Obama's Rout Rejiggers the Race ] Using the Race Issue to Carve Up the Electorate ] Voting for devil you know ] [ Why Isn't Poverty an Issue? ] When is a Bargain a Challenge ] GOP fears charges of racism, sexism ] Fox Attacks Black America ] Bill Clinton talks of race and politics ] Walking on Eggshells ] The New Black ] 'Barack Hussein Obama' an all-American name ] Ferraro's Affirmative Action Offense ] Ferraro puts her foot in her mouth ] Voters try to look beyond race when picking candidates ] Pride, Patriotism and Black Americans ]
Child Level:
Home ] Up ]
Parent Level:
What is Institutional Racism? ] Institutional Racism in America ] January 2008 Articles ] March 2008 Articles ] Racial Inequality in America ] February 2008 Articles ]
[Race and Racial Groups] [Citizenship Rights]  [Justice and Race] [Patterns of Basic Needs] [Intersectionality Issues] [Human Rights]

Always Under Construction!

Always Under Construction!

Copyright @ 2008
Vernellia Randall. All Rights Reserved

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, some material on this website is provided for comment, background information, research and/or educational purposes only, without permission from the copyright owner(s), under the "fair use" provisions of the federal copyright laws. These materials may not be distributed for other purposes without permission of the copyright owner(s).


Last Updated:
Tuesday, April 07, 2009  

You are visitor number
Hit Counter  
Since January 9, 2008